A Local's Guide to the Best Coffee and Pizza Combinations in Middletown

Mar 07, 2025

Exploring Middletown’s Coffee and Pizza Scene

Welcome to Middletown, a charming locale where the aroma of freshly brewed coffee mingles with the tantalizing scent of pizza straight from the oven. For both locals and visitors, discovering the perfect coffee and pizza combination can be a delightful adventure. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or just looking for a cozy spot to relax, Middletown offers an array of options that promise an unforgettable culinary experience.

In this guide, we’ll take you through some of the best coffee and pizza pairings in town. From bustling cafes to quaint pizzerias, you’ll find everything you need to satisfy your taste buds while exploring this vibrant community.

coffee pizza

The Classic Combo

Espresso and Margherita Pizza

If you’re a fan of traditional flavors, the classic combination of a robust espresso with a simple yet flavorful Margherita pizza is a must-try. The rich, bold taste of espresso complements the fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato sauce beautifully. Many local cafes serve this pairing with an added touch of authenticity, making it a favorite among purists.

Where to Find It

Visit “Joe's Artisan Coffee” for their renowned espresso. Just a short walk away, “Middletown Pizzeria” creates an exquisite Margherita that makes this pairing a dream come true. Both establishments pride themselves on using high-quality ingredients, ensuring that each bite and sip is perfection.

espresso margherita

Adventurous Pairings

Latte and BBQ Chicken Pizza

For those who love to venture beyond the ordinary, try pairing a creamy latte with a smoky BBQ chicken pizza. The smooth texture of the latte balances the savory and slightly spicy flavors of the pizza, offering a delightful contrast that will leave your taste buds craving more.

Where to Find It

Head over to “The Brew House,” known for their expertly crafted lattes. Then, make your way to “Slice of Heaven,” where their BBQ chicken pizza is a local favorite. This combo is perfect for those who enjoy a mix of comfort and adventure in their meals.

latte bbq chicken pizza

Sweet Meets Savory

Cappuccino and Prosciutto Fig Pizza

If you have a penchant for sweet and savory combinations, a frothy cappuccino paired with a prosciutto fig pizza might just be your new favorite. The sweetness of figs and the saltiness of prosciutto are beautifully enhanced by the rich, foamy texture of a well-prepared cappuccino.

Where to Find It

You can taste this delightful pairing at “Café Delight,” where they serve one of the best cappuccinos in town. Adjacent to it is “Piazza Gourmet,” where the prosciutto fig pizza is crafted to perfection. This duo is a testament to how diverse flavors can harmonize effortlessly.

cappuccino prosciutto pizza

Combining Local Favorites

Cold Brew and Veggie Delight Pizza

For a refreshing twist, try pairing a cold brew coffee with a veggie delight pizza. The crispness of cold brew complements the vibrant flavors of seasonal vegetables topped on a thin crust. It’s a refreshing combination that’s particularly enjoyable during warmer days.

Where to Find It

“Bean & Leaf” is renowned for its refreshing cold brew options. Meanwhile, “Green Oven” specializes in veggie pizzas that are both healthy and delicious. This combination is ideal for those who appreciate fresh ingredients and invigorating beverages.

Whether you're in Middletown for a day or a lifetime, these coffee and pizza combinations are sure to enhance your culinary journey. Enjoy exploring these local gems and uncover your own favorite pairings in this delightful town!