A Local's Guide to the Best Pizza in Middletown

Apr 30, 2025

Introduction to Middletown's Pizza Scene

Middletown, a charming blend of historic charm and modern flair, is home to some of the best pizza spots in the region. Whether you're a fan of thin crust, deep dish, or something in between, Middletown offers a variety of options that cater to all tastes. Join us as we explore some local favorites that make Middletown a pizza lover's paradise.

local pizzeria

Classic Pizzerias with a Rich History

Some of Middletown's pizzerias have been serving delicious slices for decades, becoming an integral part of the community. These establishments pride themselves on family recipes and time-tested techniques.

Joe's Pizza Place

Located in the heart of downtown, Joe's Pizza Place is a landmark that has delighted locals for over 30 years. Known for its crispy crust and generous toppings, Joe's offers a classic menu that never disappoints. Don't miss their signature margherita pizza, a crowd favorite.

Italiano's Pizzeria

Italiano's, with its rustic decor and inviting atmosphere, offers a genuine taste of Italy right here in Middletown. Their wood-fired ovens impart a unique flavor to their pizzas, making each bite unforgettable. Be sure to try their quattro formaggi pizza for a cheesy delight.

wood fired pizza

Modern Twists on Traditional Favorites

If you're in the mood to try something new, Middletown's innovative pizzerias are pushing the boundaries with creative toppings and unique flavors. These modern spots are perfect for adventurous eaters looking to shake up their usual pizza routine.

The Gourmet Slice

The Gourmet Slice brings a culinary twist to traditional pizza with toppings like truffle oil, goat cheese, and arugula. Their rotating seasonal specials ensure there's always something new to try. The pear and gorgonzola pizza should be at the top of your list.

Pizza Fusion

Pizza Fusion prides itself on using organic ingredients and sustainable practices. Their menu features a variety of vegan and gluten-free options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious slice. The spicy vegan sausage pizza is a standout choice for those who love a little heat.

gourmet pizza

Family-Friendly Pizzerias

Middletown is known for its family-friendly dining options, and its pizzerias are no exception. Many local spots offer welcoming environments and kid-friendly menus, making them perfect for a family outing.

Papa's Pizza Parlor

Papa's Pizza Parlor is a hit with families thanks to its fun atmosphere and extensive menu that caters to all ages. Kids love their make-your-own-pizza option, where they can choose their favorite toppings and watch their pizza come to life.

Sunny's Pizza

Sunny's offers a laid-back vibe with plenty of seating for large groups. Their family combo deals provide great value without sacrificing quality. Don't forget to end your meal with their famous dessert pizza, topped with chocolate and strawberries.

Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Slice

No matter what kind of pizza you crave, Middletown has something to satisfy every palate. From traditional pizzerias with rich histories to modern spots serving up creative flavors, the town is bursting with exceptional choices. Next time you're in Middletown, be sure to explore these local gems and discover your new favorite slice.